Bavarian-Board.co.uk - BMW Owners Discussion Forum Homepage
Forum Home Forum Home > Technical & Model Specific Forums > BMW 5 Series
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Hit a curb - Snow chaos
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Register Register  Login Login

Forum LockedHit a curb - Snow chaos

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>
Author
Message
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: Hit a curb - Snow chaos
    Posted: 24-January-2010 at 18:30

Recently I was driving on snow covered road and near a turn I could not manage to turn quickly enough and hit a curb. Well I was doing probably 5-10 mph then turned the steering wheel slowly but car kept going straight; slight braking did not help either. My left side front wheel hit the curb from side. It was bit noisy and I thought some serious damage has been done. Stopped then looked at the impacted wheel and could not see anything wrong at all. I was surprised and carried on my journey. But soon I realized that not everything is ok. I could feel that left wheel isn't moving 100% freely; it is having extra friction for part of its rotation.

Today I jacked that wheel up and tried to rotate it by hand and it was not moving freely. For part of rotation (appx 40-60 degrees) it was bit jam and then it moved with less friction afterwards. This behaviour was as if something is rubbing off the wheel at somepoint. I could not find anything obvious causing the problem!

Is this a total screwup or just big alignment issue? How hard it is to fix? Is this going to be pocket draining?

Worth mentioning that steering is slightly off center and car follows road on its own based on road gradient. But this behaviour is since before this accident.

Thanks for reading.

Back to Top
Sponsored Links


Back to Top
540 V8 View Drop Down
Bavarian-Board Contributor
Bavarian-Board Contributor
Avatar
Lick my badge

Joined: 07-December-2005
Location: Running the asylum
Status: Offline
Points: 2280
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote 540 V8 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 24-January-2010 at 22:01

From what you say, you may hve damaged the wheel bearing or perhaps knocked the caliper slightly off it's mount though wheel bearing seems more likely. If you jack the wheel up, try and shake the wheel by grabbing the top and bottom and try rocking it back and forth. If you get play this way then there is definatley a problem. Strange thing is, you usually damage the wheel/suspension/tyre more often than not and to have no damage to that but the symptoms you explain seems a little strange. If the wheel is 'grabbing' then there is something out of line in conjunction with the rotational direction of the wheel. I'd take the wheel off and see if there is anything obvious and if not sounds like a visit to a garage may be in order.

Fingers crossed it's nothing too serious. I wouldn't risk driving it though, not long journeys or fast anyway!

Mike


Current:E34 540i Touring 6 speed manual(Mpower bodykit & suspension)& Chrysler Voyager 3.3 V6 auto
Previous:E34 530iSE AC Schnitzer suspension.
E28 525e auto-Standard
Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 24-January-2010 at 22:37

Thanks for answering.

Car is still under warranty. I know this kind of faults won't be convered under warranty but is it worth trying?

 

Back to Top
Andrew Rolland View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Go away rain

Joined: 19-August-2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 6579
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Andrew Rolland Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 25-January-2010 at 09:04

Originally posted by afsar afsar wrote:

Car is still under warranty. I know this kind of faults won't be convered under warranty but is it worth trying?

Accident damage will not be covered by warranty.  Might be worth a try but depending on how strict they are, they might see thru it as accident damage and not do it for free.  You might be lucky, my wife got a crakced wishbone done on her Escort within a few months of hitting a pothole under warranty.

Are you sure the grabbing isn't just the brake pads rubbing on the disc?

I recently hit a pothole which mangled one of my front alloys, no damage on the outside of the rim but the inside of it was bent in on itself.  Car then started to pull to left and had a vibration.  Needed new alloy, tyre and a full four wheel alignment where the tracking was adjusted.  Afterwards car tracks straight and true with no vibration.

Take it to a garage for a full four wheel alignmanet and ask them to check over the suspension. 



Edited by Andrew Rolland
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto
Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 25-January-2010 at 10:45
Originally posted by Andrew Rolland Andrew Rolland wrote:

Originally posted by afsar afsar wrote:

Car is still
under warranty. I know this kind of faults won't be
convered under warranty but is it worth trying?


Accident damage will not be covered by warranty. 
Might be worth a try but depending on how strict they
are, they might see thru it as accident damage and not do
it for free.  You might be lucky, my wife got a crakced
wishbone done on her Escort within a few months of
hitting a pothole under warranty.


Are you sure the grabbing isn't just the brake pads
rubbing on the disc?


I recently hit a pothole which mangled one of my front
alloys, no damage on the outside of the rim but the
inside of it was bent in on itself.  Car then started
to pull to left and had a vibration.  Needed new alloy,
tyre and a full four wheel alignment where the tracking
was adjusted.  Afterwards car tracks straight and true
with no vibration.


Take it to a garage for a full four wheel alignmanet
and ask them to check over the suspension. 


How do I know if brake pads are rubbing off the disc? Any
quick way of verifying that.
Back to Top
Andrew Rolland View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Go away rain

Joined: 19-August-2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 6579
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Andrew Rolland Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26-January-2010 at 08:37

No easy way other than experience.  You can hear a light rubbing noise or light grinding that comes from the caliper/brake pad area.

Other than that you could get an idea from spinning the other front wheel to gauge the resistance.

Probably best taking it to a garage incase you have damaged something.

Reading your first post again, I'm guessing that your tracking was out before the accident as you said "steering is slightly off centre".  It's worth getting it sorted now and in doing so, they will check the suspension components for damage.  Not to mention that you have probably been scrubbing your tyres slightly with the steering being off centre.

Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto
Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26-January-2010 at 09:16
Booked in for tomorrow at BMW dealership, lets see if they
do it under warranty or rip me off.
Back to Top
540 V8 View Drop Down
Bavarian-Board Contributor
Bavarian-Board Contributor
Avatar
Lick my badge

Joined: 07-December-2005
Location: Running the asylum
Status: Offline
Points: 2280
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote 540 V8 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 26-January-2010 at 20:18

Originally posted by afsar afsar wrote:

Booked in for tomorrow at BMW dealership, lets see if they
do it under warranty or rip me off.

Is it worth trying the insurance company? If you have protected no claims you could get the lot done for the cost of your excess?

Most mechanics, especially at main dealers aren't stupid, they will spot the difference between wear and tear and accident damage. Your best bet is to ask them to check it over and quote you for any work before they carry it out and make sure you get the quote in writing before you say yes!

Mike


Current:E34 540i Touring 6 speed manual(Mpower bodykit & suspension)& Chrysler Voyager 3.3 V6 auto
Previous:E34 530iSE AC Schnitzer suspension.
E28 525e auto-Standard
Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 27-January-2010 at 21:28

Update:

Today dealer called me to inform that this won't be covered under warranty as this could have been caused by curb hit or some other form of physical damage. Luck didn't work. No problem. Thanks Mike for your suggestion to ask for written quote before billing meter starts. So they gave me a quote for following items which will need replacing:

1) Wheel rim with tyres
2) Disc and pad and sensors
3) Wheel bearing and few other components with it

Total cost: £2448.00 ONLY.  This price also includes rear pad replacement with DISCS! My iDrive says 1800 miles to go for rear wheel pads but they said it is just 3mm so now disc will need replacing. I am not bothered about this now, will see later.

I told them that I am in a state of shock, once I recover then I will call you back tomorrow. Don't do any work until I place orders.

As you can easily guess I will take my car from them tomrrow (they need to fit new radio console button which is under warranty repair) and then I will speak to a local mechanic near my office. I can't see any problem with the wheel with the naked eye but I am not sure if there is something beyond visibility. Also I think if wheels are having any kind of problem then car will vibrate badly on higher speed and I won't have to struggle to feel the rubbing vibration. Anyway not sure on this.As Mike and Andy said it could be wheel bearing and/or pads rubbing on the disc.

Guys, from bmwfans website can you please tell me what part number I may need to buy for bearing and related component if bearing is found faulty? Should I buy from dealership or I can buy it off ebay if there is huge price difference, which I think will be the case. How about non-oem stuff? Getting this ripoff quote I am totally lost my trust with the main dealer, they always try to charge 3-5 times higher then what it will cost be in real. Last time they quoted £1000 for something which I got done for appx. £200 outside with oem parts.

Btw. how much work will be involved in this. I would love to do DIY as I am living alone for next 1 month or so and nothing much to do? Worth trying?

 

Back to Top
Andrew Rolland View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Go away rain

Joined: 19-August-2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 6579
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Andrew Rolland Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 08:30

Does sound pricey.

BMW are right to tell you that your rear pads need doing at that thickness.

What mileage have you done on the car?

You will be paying probably nearly £100 from the dealer for each set of 4 pads and each brake disc so that's probably nearly £600 for the brake parts plus say £200 for the bearing.  Say 4 hours to fit all that at £75/hour.  Your wheel and tyre will be atleast £500, I've just spent £516 getting a new rim and tyre.

What does that add up to? £1600 plus vat at 17.5 = £1880 ish?

What other bits are you needing doing?

Buying OEM parts from Eurocar parts you could halve the brake part bill.

Brakes are easy diy, not done the E60 yet but the E39 wasn't difficult. 

You are stuffed for BMW for the rim though.



Edited by Andrew Rolland
Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto
Back to Top
Ballcock View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 07-September-2006
Location: Galway
Status: Offline
Points: 208
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Ballcock Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 09:12

What is the damage to rim & tyre ? Are they just quoting for replacement of them due to the obvious impact damage to other components and making assumptions that there must be some internal damage ?

If there is no visible sign of damage to the alloy/tyre and it balances OK, then I wouldn't bother. You don't change a tyre every time you hit a pothole citing possible internal tyre damage....

And no, I'm not advising skimping on tyres, just BMW having a laugh. They aint selling too many cars this weather and are recouping costs on things like this !

If there is damage to rim, get it repaired (minor buckle only - cracked then bin it alright)

E34 Pilot - Keeping it Old School on Irish Roads.
Back to Top
Ballcock View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 07-September-2006
Location: Galway
Status: Offline
Points: 208
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Ballcock Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 12:41

Slightly O/T but an interesting read here regarding some BMW alloys being prone to cracking - not all being as a result of impact damage it would seem.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/watchdog/2009/10/bmw_alloy_wheels .html

E34 Pilot - Keeping it Old School on Irish Roads.
Back to Top
jetsetwilly2000 View Drop Down
Really Senior Member II
Really Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 10-December-2003
Location: Cambridgeshire
Status: Offline
Points: 701
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote jetsetwilly2000 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 12:53
My brother was fitting out 535dTs for breakdown techs for a while, and they replaced all the OE alloys as a matter of course because so many cracked (cars were well loaded but well within the max)

Don't bother with non-oem stuff, just go to ECP, GSF or motormec, should be way less than the stealer prices.

For a simple wheel/tyre check, do the other work and then swap the fronts over, and see what that feels like.
E90 M3 DCT, E46 330d Touring, VW T5 wannabecamper

Previous: Disco 3 TDV6, 2x E34 540i6,

E34 535iS

Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 14:01
My car has done 27k miles on the clock. Wheel is 172 style
so costs a bit more, they said it is 350+ without VAT. They
calculated almost whole wheel and other axle assembly for
that side, even the thickness sensors! Today I will see the
quote in writing once I go to collect my car. I would post
each item here.
I can confirm that I did not see any cracks on the alloys
neither I could see any buckling. dealer is telling it is
all buckled up. Can that be repaired if there aren't any
cracks?

I will check wheel bearing myself over the weekend.
Back to Top
Andrew Rolland View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Go away rain

Joined: 19-August-2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 6579
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Andrew Rolland Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 14:35

You won't be able to fix a buckled alloy yourself to a suitable standard.

The crakced wheel reference above will not have been what BMW have picked up on your wheel if it has signs of loosing an argument with a kerb.

27,000 miles and you need new rear pads and discs!  You must be driving everwhere with the traction control on  I've done 26,000 miles in mine since I've got it and the service interval for the rear pads gets longer the more I drive it.  Go figure that, cos I can't!

Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto
Back to Top
jetsetwilly2000 View Drop Down
Really Senior Member II
Really Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 10-December-2003
Location: Cambridgeshire
Status: Offline
Points: 701
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote jetsetwilly2000 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 15:11
Bayesian probability dear boy.  The car calculates your pads' life based on their current thickness and some (probably preset) estimate of the wear rate.  However, if it overestimates, and your pads stay thicker for longer, then it has to recalculate from the new start point.  But if it still overestimates the wear rate then it'll do the same thing repeatedly.  A cleverer system would learn the wear rate, but even so it'll only be a rough prediction based on the past.

It's like estimating your lifespan.  Based on the population stats, at birth you might have a 20% chance of living to see 80, but at 75 it's more like 70%.  Had fun explaining that to my dad a few years ago!


Edited by jetsetwilly2000
E90 M3 DCT, E46 330d Touring, VW T5 wannabecamper

Previous: Disco 3 TDV6, 2x E34 540i6,

E34 535iS

Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 15:16
Originally posted by Andrew Rolland Andrew Rolland wrote:

You won't be able to fix a
buckled alloy yourself to a suitable standard.

No no, I
won't try to do it myself. I would like to get it done by a
professional. And yes I drive traction on and sometimes
press hard.


Is it good excuse to get my wheel upgraded to 20"
I checked eBay and found JADE R alloys for
appx £1200, are they worth it? I am not into wheels so
never heard Jade R before but look wise it was impressive.
I anyway need four new tyres, rear ones has 3mm tread left
and front has many cuts and bruises.
Back to Top
Ballcock View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 07-September-2006
Location: Galway
Status: Offline
Points: 208
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Ballcock Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 28-January-2010 at 16:44

Originally posted by afsar afsar wrote:

 
I checked eBay and found JADE R alloys for
appx £1200, are they worth it?

Pure muck - stay away. They'll buckle much quicker than any BMW wheels the first pothole you hit. I'd still look at getting the wheel refurb'd if only a minor buckle.

Get BMW to point out exactly where it's buckled and make a judgement yourself. Alloy wheel repair technology has come on a lot since the days of a lump hammer and scaffold pole.....

E34 Pilot - Keeping it Old School on Irish Roads.
Back to Top
Andrew Rolland View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Go away rain

Joined: 19-August-2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 6579
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Andrew Rolland Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 29-January-2010 at 08:49

20" alloys!

You'll have no spine left!

Way too bling for me.

Be exclusive and drive a Petrol 5 Series!

Current
'13 62 F10 535i MSport Auto

Previous
'04 04 E60 545i SE Auto
'03 53 E60 545i SE Auto (Stolen)
'98 S E39 523i SE Auto
Back to Top
afsar View Drop Down
Senior Member II
Senior Member II
Avatar

Joined: 25-November-2007
Status: Offline
Points: 172
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote afsar Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 29-January-2010 at 09:53
Originally posted by Andrew Rolland Andrew Rolland wrote:

20" alloys!


You'll have no spine left!


Way too bling for me.


I am not going for it anymore.
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.156 seconds.