suspension or what else....
Printed From: Bavarian-Board.co.uk - BMW Owners Discussion Forum
Category: Technical & Model Specific Forums
Forum Name: BMW 5 Series
Forum Discription: This forum will deal with any issues on the BMW 5 Series (E12, E28, E34, E39, E60 & E61)
URL: http://www.bavarian-board.co.uk/forum_posts.asp?TID=9281
Printed Date: 17-June-2024 at 19:19
Topic: suspension or what else....
Posted By: toonraider
Subject: suspension or what else....
Date Posted: 21-July-2004 at 21:18
|
can be wrong now????? My 535 has just had new bilstien rear shocks and eibach springs and all is great(on the rear) altho a little spongy and wallowy still. Going by my mechanics advice the front shocks were sound so only the springs were replaced on the front. Now though every drain in the road etc and even getting onto my drive creates a heavy knocking sound from the front and sometimes i even feel it through the steering column!!!! Do you think that maybe the front shocks are a little soft?? I even had the anti roll bar drop links and front and rear top mounts and upper control arm bushings changed at the same time. I`m not a happy chap and not exactly the governor of the bank of England.!!! I need some help guys..........please. |
Replies:
Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 21-July-2004 at 23:09
|
Did the garage that carried out the work put the suspension back correctly and tighten all the nuts and bolts back up to the correct torque ? I assume you did not have this knocking before the front springs and suspension components were changed ?
Miles -------------  
1991 525i Sport Manual http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0"> 
|
Posted By: toonraider
Date Posted: 22-July-2004 at 09:25
|
yep. i even took it back to be re-checked and it was all fine. One thing tho is that when the car is on the hoist/ramp and you physically grab the wheel and lift it and then let go, one of them(drivers side) rests again with a bump/knock and the other side makes no noise. Thats why i thought that maybe the shocks may be on their way out. Just a thought but could it be the subframe bushes, thats if its got one(total stab in the dark)? |
Posted By: Deathace
Date Posted: 22-July-2004 at 11:10
|
Thats sounds like a problem i had with another car it turned out to be the wheel bearings, i dont know if the same applies to bmw's but its worth a look. Russ ------------- http://www.deathace.net">  
1990 535i SE Auto Metallic Glacier Blue, Low Mileage, M-Tech Bodykit, Full Leather & Various Custom Mods. |
Posted By: jontunstall
Date Posted: 22-July-2004 at 11:35
|
Hi, I had this problem on mine 520 touring, when I accidentally left off the concave washer which sits on the top of the strut below the top plate. it makes no noise until you go over a bump and then clunk. Try sliding the rubber protectors down and see if you can see the washer? I dont know if you can but its wortha a look as it is easily missable - was for me anyway. Good luck jon |
Posted By: toonraider
Date Posted: 29-July-2004 at 20:59
| ok, i couldn`t put up with the noise the front supension made every time i went over a slight crack in the road so i stumped up the cash(again) to get the front shockers changed,inserts only, but still bilstien. So, new inserts and eibach springs, a little lighter in the back pocket area and...still bloody knocking. All other bushes have been checked and are fine and i even had the drop link bushes changed aswell. What could be causing all the aggro ? |
Posted By: b8alk
Date Posted: 29-July-2004 at 22:13
|
poss supension top mount bushes or as miles as said it has not been put back together correctly.it might be worth booking it in a bmw,s and getting them to go over it for you that will cost you about £70.00 but could save you money in the long run ------------- E34 M30 535i SPORT  
|
Posted By: e34m5
Date Posted: 30-July-2004 at 20:40
|
When the shocks were changed did the garage you used check to see if the rubber spring pads were in good condition ? The uppers drivers side pad was perished on my car and I think this is what was causing a slight knocking on my car.
Miles -------------
1991 525i Sport Manual http://forum.bmw5.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=3552&st=0">
|
Posted By: toonraider
Date Posted: 30-July-2004 at 22:18
| forgot to mention earlier, i also had the front and rear top mounts changed also. Bloody costly mind. The mechanic i use is very good and trustworthy, but to me it feels and sounds as if the control arms or subframe bushes or something similar because over bumps etc it the front of the car feels loose and unstable a little. The knock noise is not loud, just a deep rumble. Going back tomorrow for thorough check. But in the meantime.......help !!!!! |